Last month, a friend with whom I tend to attend concerts called me with an extra ticket to a sold-out Dresden Dolls show at the Paradise Rock Club in Boston. Familiar with the locally-based band only in passing, I liked what I knew of them. However, their self-description perplexed me: “Brechtian punk cabaret” (As much as I love creative descriptions of one’s own sound, they often serve more to make a potential listener curious than to give him an accurate concept of what the band actually sounds like.) Arriving at the Paradise, the “cabaret” part was immediately apparent from the opening acts: human marionettes; a fascinating fellow named Thomas Truax, who played an instrument of his own invention called the Hornicator; and an Australian contortionist.
After much anticipation (some of it nervous, as many in the crowd were outfitted in punk-goth combos, and I was wearing jeans and a sweater), the Dresden Dolls took the stage. I am often skeptical of musicians who wear make-up when they perform; I tend to associate them with aloof and posturing stage presences. But Amanda Palmer (the strikingly charismatic vocalist/pianist) and Brian Viglione (the drummer and, for a few songs, guitarist) presently transcended the white face paint and the sometimes-hokey opening acts. Their connection with the audience was palpable. The make-up and black and white punk-Victorian outfits served to lend an air of theatricality, yes (the “Brecht” part?), but by no means did the style ever trump the substance.
Occasionally they struck me as what Ben Folds Five might have sounded like had they performed in Weimar Germany at the Kit Kat Club fronted by an angrier and less British Kate Winslet (indeed, Brian reminded me somewhat of Joel Grey’s Emcee, even excepting the make-up and eventual lack of shirt). Like BF5, the DDs bring a unique approach to punk rock by replacing the traditional guitar with a piano – in this case without the benefit of a bass – and in doing so, sound less punk than… well, something else. Comparisons to other female piano-playing singer/songwriters are inevitable, but inaccurate. The music is not nearly as baroque as Fiona Apple and never enters the Lilith Fair territory of Tori Amos. It incorporates elements of twisted lullaby, broken music box and friendly carnival midway without ever obscuring the emotional power of Amanda’s lyrics. “Brechtian punk cabaret” does them plenty of justice, but in the end really only accurately depicts their live show and overall aesthetic. Upon listening only to their recorded work (one self-titled studio album and a live album “A is for Accident”) it’s clear that the Dresden Dolls simply play pop songs, however gothic. But don’t take my word for it: you can download several mp3s from their website. (Also – providing you like what you hear – be sure to check out the link to a video of the Dresden Dolls on Morning Becomes Eclectic.) “Half Jack” (sung from the point of view of a hermaphrodite) is a particularly compelling example.
As the night wore on, the show grew increasingly personal. I became an unwitting attendant to the Dresden Dolls’ good-bye-to-Boston party. Twice Amanda began aborted confessions to the conflicted feelings spurred by leaving the nurturing confines of America’s largest small town for the impending national spotlight (in a mere three days, fate would find them on tour as support for Nine Inch Nails). She addressed both her close friends in the balcony and her fans in general the same way: as a group of confidantes. The audience that night was a group representative of the place the Dresden Dolls called home. The city that will soon become no more than “where they came from.”
It turned out to be Amanda’s birthday later in the week (her thirtieth, about which she had reservations – “You’re not old!” the audience reassured her). At the end of the night, she took large handfuls of the birthday cake her friends had brought up on stage and fed them to eager fans at the front of the stage. It didn’t matter that prior to the concert I had known a total of three Dresden Dolls songs. I had been witness to (and participant in) the end of one chapter in the existence of a band.